Imagine getting hit with a wave of chargebacks right after Shopify sunsets its built-in fraud filter. You’re left scrambling, digging through the App Store, unsure which tool will protect your business. That’s when finding the right Shopify fraud filter app becomes critical, not just something that works, but something you can trust day to day.
| What you’ll find in this guide: ● 10 top-rated Shopify fraud prevention apps ● Hands-on insights from real merchant experience ● Key features and pricing breakdown ● Bonus: How to pick the right app for your store size and risk level |
I’ve reviewed dozens of fraud prevention apps on Shopify and narrowed them down to the ten that truly deliver. This ranking is based on a mix of real-world performance, user reviews, feature depth, and hands-on experience. I’ve kept things fair, practical, and focused on what matters when you’re running a store and need protection that works.
Blockify is the first Shopify fraud filter app I recommend when someone asks how to stop shady orders on Shopify. It has over 575 reviews and a glowing 4.9★ rating on the App Store, and for good reason. Since Shopify killed off its built-in fraud filter, Blockify has pretty much filled the gap, and then some.
What I love most is how easy it is to get started. The UI is clean, you don’t need to be a developer to figure things out, and it works straight out of the box. If your store constantly gets hit by bots, VPNs, or orders from suspicious countries, this app can seriously save your day (and your money).
Here’s what Blockify helps you do:
If you’re running a higher-volume store or selling higher-priced items, NoFraud is a solid contender. It has a decent 4.6★ rating across Shopify and third-party sources, plus it offers one thing Blockify doesn’t: a chargeback guarantee. That means if NoFraud approves an order and it turns out to be fraud, they’ll cover the loss. Sounds great, right?
Well… yes and no. In my experience, the setup process is a bit more involved than Blockify. There are more settings to tweak, and while that gives you flexibility, it can also be overwhelming at first. It’s more of a “set up and manage” kind of app, whereas Blockify is “set up and forget.” Also, their UI feels a little dated compared to Blockify’s cleaner design, not a dealbreaker, but worth mentioning.
Here’s what NoFraud brings to the table:
ClearSale has been in the fraud prevention game for over 20 years, and you can feel that maturity in how the app works. It currently holds a 3.9★ rating on Shopify and is especially popular with merchants who deal with international orders or high-ticket products.
Personally, I think ClearSale strikes a good balance between automation and real human review. The app flags suspicious orders using machine learning, but what’s unique is that their team of fraud analysts actually steps in to review borderline cases. That gives me a little extra peace of mind, especially on those orders where you’re just not sure.
Here’s what you get with ClearSale:
I’ve got to say, SEON feels more like a full-blown fraud platform than just a Shopify app. The first time I opened it, I was impressed by how deep it goes. But I also knew right away: this isn’t for everyone.
If you’re running a small store, it might feel like overkill. The dashboard is packed with data, risk signals, scoring tools… and that’s before you even touch the settings. But if you love seeing the “why” behind every fraud flag, SEON’s got you covered. It currently holds a 4.4★ rating with 47 verified reviews.
Main features worth noting:
If you’re running a larger Shopify store, or just tired of dealing with chargebacks, Signifyd is a name worth knowing. It’s not just a fraud filter; it’s a full-blown commerce protection platform that covers everything from order validation to chargeback recovery.
In my experience, Signifyd feels more “hands-off.” Once it’s plugged in, it takes over the heavy lifting, approving legitimate orders, flagging the risky ones, and backing you up financially if something slips through. With over 80 reviews and a 4.0★ rating on Shopify, it’s earned the trust of scaling brands.
Main features worth noting:
FraudBlock is built for one thing: automatically canceling high-risk orders before they hit your fulfillment queue. It’s a clean, no-frills tool that does exactly what it promises.
The app holds a 4.7★ rating on Shopify, backed by over 29 reviews from merchants who rely on it daily. I like how quietly it runs. Once you define your rules, it just does its job, no popups, no second-guessing. That said, it’s better suited for stores that already trust Shopify’s fraud analysis and just want to automate the next step.
Here’s what stands out:
Beacon Shopify fraud filter app aims to give merchants more control over how fraud rules work, instead of relying solely on Shopify’s default risk labels. It’s more hands-on than some of the other apps on this list, which can be a good or bad thing depending on how comfortable you are tweaking logic.
It’s currently rated 4.7★ on Shopify, with a smaller but loyal user base, and around 12+ public reviews. I’ve tried it on a test store and appreciated how flexible the rule system is. You can combine multiple conditions, set custom actions, and even delay fulfillment based on risk. The only thing I didn’t love was the interface, a bit dense in some places, but you get used to it fast.
Key highlights include:
I came across Fraud Judge while looking for an app that could handle identity and address validation, and honestly, it surprised me. It’s not flashy, but it does its job well. Each order goes through real-time screening, and you can set up rules to auto-verify or block based on specific criteria.
What stood out to me was the ID verification prompt. You can ask customers to submit extra info for risky orders, which is great if you’re selling high-value or age-restricted items. Support was fast, the setup was quick, and I noticed fewer chargebacks right away. The app currently holds a 4.9★ rating on Shopify, with over 20 reviews, most of them glowing.
Here’s what it handles best:
Eye4Fraud is suitable for merchants who want simplicity with serious fraud insurance. You get automatic protection and hands-on support, without needing to manage complex settings.
It guarantees fraud protection, meaning if a fraudulent order slips through, they cover the loss. That promise has earned them a 4.9★ rating and numerous 5-star reviews on the Shopify App Store, where users consistently highlight “proactive support” and “fraud caught before shipping” as major wins.
Tools it puts in your hands:
To help you choose the right fraud protection app without second-guessing, I’ve summarized the top 10 Shopify fraud filter app in the table below:
| App Name | Rating | Monthly Cost | Best For | Key Features | Free Plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blockify Fraud Filter | ⭐ 4.9 (575+) | From $7.99/month | Stores needing fast, no-code setup | Block by country/IP/proxy, auto-cancel rules, email/phone filtering, geo-blocking, live dashboard | ✅ |
| NoFraud | ⭐ 4.6 | Custom pricing | High-value orders & chargeback protection | Machine learning analysis, manual review, fraud score, chargeback guarantee, cross-platform integration | ❌ |
| ClearSale | ⭐ 3.9 | Custom pricing | International or high-ticket stores | AI + manual fraud review, chargeback dispute support, real-time scoring, Shopify integration | ❌ |
| SEON | ⭐ 4.4 (47) | From $699/month | Data-driven teams with dev resources | 90+ real-time signals, custom rule engine, email/phone enrichment, visual risk dashboard | ✅ |
| Signifyd | ⭐ 4.0 | Custom pricing | Shopify Plus or enterprise stores | AI scoring, instant decision-making, chargeback reimbursement, global shopper database | ❌ |
| FraudBlock | ⭐ 4.7 | $19.95/month (Pro) | Simple automation based on Shopify’s risk labels | Auto-cancel high-risk orders, restock, notify staff, and fast setup | ✅ |
| Beacon | ⭐ 4.7 | Custom pricing | Merchants needing rule flexibility | Custom rules, conditional logic, delay fulfillment, tagging | ❌ |
| Fraud Judge | ⭐ 4.9 | $20/month | High-risk or age-restricted items | ID/address verification, blacklists, real-time screening, age check | ✅ |
| Eye4Fraud | ⭐ 4.9 | Custom pricing | Full-service protection with support | Guaranteed fraud insurance, auto-cancel/refund, phone + ID checks, international support | ❌ |
Real-time detection Shopify fraud filter app helps you block fraudulent orders before they’re processed. Instead of relying on delayed reviews, you get instant action that prevents chargebacks.
More importantly, it allows you to focus on fulfilling good orders quickly. This ensures your customer experience stays smooth while fraud is handled in the background.
Some apps include chargeback guarantees; they’ll pay you back if a chargeback slips through. That can offer serious peace of mind, especially for high-ticket items.
However, not all guarantees are the same. Be sure to read the terms carefully to understand what’s covered and what counts as “eligible.”
Rule-based filters let you create custom triggers based on your store’s patterns. They’re great if you know what suspicious behavior looks like in your niche.
On the flip side, machine learning systems analyze more data over time. They adapt automatically to detect evolving fraud trends you may not see coming.
Some apps offer a hybrid approach where Shopify risky orders are reviewed by real analysts. This reduces false positives and lets good customers through.
While automation is fast, human review adds an extra layer of accuracy. It’s a good fit if your products are expensive or shipped internationally.
Choose apps that integrate seamlessly with Shopify and tools like Flow. This lets you automate actions such as canceling risky orders or tagging them for review.
As your store grows, automation becomes essential. It reduces human error and ensures consistent handling of fraudulent activity.
Fraud apps often charge per order, per decision, or per month. Understanding the pricing model ensures you won’t be surprised by sudden spikes.
Furthermore, watch for volume caps or hidden charges. The best apps offer scalable pricing that grows with your store, not against it.
Conclusion
Shopify fraud filter app isn’t a “nice-to-have” anymore; it’s essential, especially now that Shopify’s native tool is gone. Whether you need a fast fix like Blockify or a robust system like Signifyd, the right app can save you thousands in lost revenue and peace of mind. Pick one that fits your store’s size, tech comfort level, and risk exposure. Most offer free trials, so test a couple before committing.
Need help integrating your new app or migrating from the old fraud filter? Let me know, I’ve got steps and tips ready.
